Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: my thoughts

The book (and a free tote bag)In the past, when I've taken notes or "live-blogged" a new Harry Potter book, it's been mostly because I knew that when reading later books, I would want to look back at notes from earlier books - especially hints and clues that seemed relevant but weren't covered in that book (and were potentially being saved for later). That's one of the sad things about HP7: there are no later books! But I think these notes will serve two purposes:

  1. to record my first reaction to things and theories as the book goes on (like in book 6, where every few pages I had a different theory as to who the Half-Blood Prince was)
  2. to make notes of particularly amusing parts of the book so that I know where to find them when I'm looking for them later when I'm rereading the series over and over again

Here goes nothing. You are welcome to read along, comment on your own theories or things you found amusing... but please don't spoil anything for me if you're ahead of me! In return, I will try not to spoil things for you: the notes will be marked with chapter numbers (I tried just page numbers last time but that doesn't match up for all versions), so if you have the willpower, you should be able to stick to only the chapters that you've already read. Or you can just wait until we're both done.

Pre-Potter

  • 11:15pm - I arrive at the bookstore. The crowd isn't very big so I go to Starbucks.
  • 11:20 or so - I go and sit outside with the other Harry Potter fans. There was one little girl dressed like Luna Lovegood who made me want to cry. I don't know why. Harry Potter makes me all emotional. I think I'm preparing for all the DEATHS. Don't kill Luna Lovegood! That girl was so cute!
  • 11:30 - Doors open. We go inside and explore. I make an origami snitch and eat a licorice wand, then get in line.
  • 12:00 - Book is distributed to pre-pay customers (yours truly included in that group)
  • 12:11 - Book is in my hands
  • 12:20 - I arrive at home, change into pyjamas, talk to Cheryl on the phone, make myself a cup of tea, prepare snacks
  • 12:47 - Time to begin!

srah - Saturday, 21 July 2007 - 12:47 AM
Tags: ,


Comments (32)

gravatar Aunt pam - July 21, 2007 - 2:24 AM -

Hey Niece! If you go to yahoo.com you can listen to J. K. Rowland read the first chapter. Andrea just came home from the bookstore after accompanying her best friend. She got a cool little gift bag with glow-in-the-dark Harry Potter glasses and a key chain with a Hogwort graduation tassle. Love your origami snitch though!

gravatar Jamie - July 21, 2007 - 4:33 PM -

Pyjamas is spelled with a Y in the UK version. Just in case nobody has answered that so far. I can't look at the other comments for fear of being spoiled.

gravatar Denzylle - July 21, 2007 - 4:36 PM -

Pleased to hear you were listening to Paul Simon.

And I have to admire your dedication - four hours last night and seven so far today...?

Keep going, girl.

Denzylle-who-has-read-who-dies.

gravatar Tony - July 21, 2007 - 6:21 PM -

Personally, I think that they should have released the book in limited production at first, just like they used to do with toys in the '80s around Christmas time. Or like Apple does today, for that matter.

I would have loved to have watched the 'Cabbage Patch Kid' style fights that ensued in the bookstores! Then you could truly say that Hairy Pimper was entertaining for everybody.

gravatar alfie - July 21, 2007 - 9:17 PM -

I loved all of the AD references. Especially "Guess who liked that idea."

gravatar alfie - July 21, 2007 - 11:16 PM -

Wasn't it him who they never asked the identifying questions of too? I hope that he hasn't been replaced, but what if it isn't Ron?

gravatar alfie - July 21, 2007 - 11:18 PM -

I still think the blond guy is going to turn out to be Aberforth.

gravatar Jamie - July 22, 2007 - 11:53 AM -

Is that called a diadem in the US version? It's called a tiara in the UK version. So there really are differences.

gravatar srah - July 22, 2007 - 12:06 PM -

That's a really bizarre change! I know what a tiara is, but I wasn't totally sure about a diadem. I wonder why they would do that.

gravatar Jamie - July 22, 2007 - 12:38 PM -

Okay, I take that last comment back. Now we have a diadem, too. This book is confusing me.

gravatar srah - July 22, 2007 - 12:41 PM -

In ours, Auntie Muriel has a tiara and Rowena Ravenclaw has a diadem.

gravatar Christine - July 22, 2007 - 1:08 PM -

Hi - never read your blog before; found it on a Google.

I enjoyed reading your reactions to the book; I haven't talked to anyone else who's read it so it was nice to hear what someone else thought. I had many of the same thoughts and reactions. I did, however, want to say that I for one was devastated when Dobby died; his and Hedwig's deaths were the most painful for me. Although he did some not-so-great things to Harry in COS, they were truly because he wanted to save Harry's life, so his heart was in the right place. He certainly redeemed himself, in my opinion, in Goblet of Fire by giving Harry the gillyweed, and the other things about him in that book endeared him to me - his taking care of Winky even though she didn't like him, his being so thrilled just to see Harry, and to get a sock from him at Christmas, his new devotion to Harry's Wheezy because he gave him a sweater...he just seems like a little sweetie-pie to me. Not to mention, it was he who told Harry about the room of requirement, and who warned him about Umbridge, and who kept Kreacher in check when he needed to. Altogether, Dobby is an extremely sympathetic character to me, and I can see why his death affected Harry so much. It certainly had me sobbing on the floor.

Althought we disagreed on that point, though, I was very glad to discover the blog of another HP fan who is so obviously intelligent and has a great sense of humor.

gravatar srah - July 22, 2007 - 1:14 PM -

I think the movie-version of Dobby has done a lot to poison me against him, too. That animated thing is creepy.

gravatar alfie - July 22, 2007 - 8:45 PM -

Sorceror's Stone - I did not cry.
Chamber of Secrets - no crying.
Prisoner of Azkaban - no crying.
Goblet of Fire - no crying.
Order of the Phoenix - When I read this one, I was bawling my eyes, but that had nothing to do with the book.
Half-Blood Prince - no crying.
Deathly Hallows - had trouble reading the last two chapters because my contacts kept getting washed around in my eyes by the tears.

gravatar alfie - July 22, 2007 - 8:45 PM -

Sorceror's Stone - I did not cry.
Chamber of Secrets - no crying.
Prisoner of Azkaban - no crying.
Goblet of Fire - no crying.
Order of the Phoenix - When I read this one, I was bawling my eyes out, but that had nothing to do with the book.
Half-Blood Prince - no crying.
Deathly Hallows - I had trouble reading the last two chapters because my contacts kept getting washed around in my eyes by the tears.

gravatar srah - July 22, 2007 - 8:48 PM -

Well aren't you brave and strong? I think I cried at the end of all of the last four. It's, like, a tradition.

gravatar Jill - July 23, 2007 - 11:56 AM -

I LOVED your recap and loved the book but was so disappointed by the epilogue, and after all this time not finding out what Harry and Co end up doing with their lives ...

gravatar J - July 23, 2007 - 12:03 PM -

I'm going to start saying "How in the name of Merlin's pants...?".

I'm going to start saying "Get off your high hippogriff!"

gravatar Amy - July 23, 2007 - 2:04 PM -

Re: Chapter 27 Horcruxes

I think Voldemort's plan was for 7 total "soul pieces," one inside himself and 6 Horcuxes: the diary, the locket, the cup, the diadem, the ring, and Nagini.

But then he accidentally/unknowingly stashed an 8th piece inside Harry.

gravatar alfie - July 23, 2007 - 4:08 PM -

I viewed it the same way, Amy.

gravatar alfie - July 23, 2007 - 4:12 PM -

Also: Neville, Neville, Neville. I love you so much, you adorable fictional character!

gravatar krista. - July 24, 2007 - 11:12 AM -

I had the same reaction as you when I had to stop reading and go out into the world--someone is going to jump on a chair in the middle of a public place and scream the ending out at me just to be spiteful (though if Stephen Colbert had been right in his 'spoiler' that Hermione was a dude, I would have forgiven him because seriously, Hermione as a dude? Pshaw!).

I was actually most saddened by Hedwig's death at first (and George's ear, really), and somehow, though I really didn't like either of them, I was struck by Remus and Tonks' deaths. I'm not sure why though.

Voldemort went too easily, I say. And even though I didn't *want* anyone else to die, I really thought based on reactions I'd heard about crying and sadness that someone else was going to die too. And then no one did, and I was kind of unfulfilled in some respects. I had a sick feeling for a while that she'd kill off McGonagall, and I'm really glad she didn't. The epilogue was one bit of eye-rolling after another for me. It wasn't up to her usual level of writing--she was trying too hard to put a nice little bow on things. And then she didn't even tell us who the new headmaster was! I really wanted to know that. And what happened to Luna? C'mon!

gravatar srah - July 24, 2007 - 12:33 PM -

I think that what upset me most about Remus/Tonks is that they both went into battle and died and left poor Teddy all alone. Although Harry and Neville had (basically) the same thing happen to them and they turned out okay.

Yeah, in some ways I'm disappointed that more characters (and more important characters) didn't die. It's not that I wanted them to, but I was psyching myself up for that and then it never came. Oh well, I cried enough over the minor characters. I was seriously bawling about people like... Colin Creevey. He was underage and he snuck into the battle and he was killed! He shouldn't have been killed! And how about his Muggle dad? How do you explain to his Muggle dad how Colin died fighting the Death Eaters?

If I got that upset about Colin Creevey, then my head might just have exploded if she'd killed off Ron.

gravatar EV - July 24, 2007 - 10:36 PM -

Hey, so I answered your creepy-thing-under-the-chair question in my comments section. It's one of the things that took me an extra read of that chapter to figure out, because it's all meta and shit. As for why he didn't die in the forest, that took me like a day to process and I was all pissy. I think the point is that Lily's charm that saved Harry's life the first time is still working, because Voldemort took his blood and kept the charm in a living body. Of course, once you get to the end and realize that the Elder Wand "would not kill" Harry because he was its true master, I feel like she totally could have used that as the explanation all along, and the Lily's blood thing was kind of contrived and silly.

gravatar srah - July 24, 2007 - 10:46 PM -

Yeah, there seemed to be too many explanations. And I wasn't clear on whether he was dead or not.

gravatar EV - July 24, 2007 - 10:48 PM -

Oh, and if you're hot for shape-shifting wolf-person cubs, you must must must read the 'Fables' comic book by Bill Willingham, on Vertigo. Shape-shifting wolf-person baby cubbies that *float*. It's my total fave, and it's been going for years so if you start reading the trades now it will take days and be very satisfying.

gravatar EV - July 24, 2007 - 11:24 PM -

And also, Ginny was freaking ROBBED in this book. PILLAGED. She was being built up as this all-powerful seventh-of-two-seventh-children wunderkind, and all she gets is her brother walking in on her big planned frenching session. She didn't get to kill *anyone*. But at least JK came through on Neville. And btw have you seen photos of the kid who plays Neville when he's not trying to look like Neville? Jail bait, for serious.

gravatar srah - July 24, 2007 - 11:29 PM -

That is really true. When I saw the 5th movie, I thought "Where did Ginny come up with those moves? JKR must have told them to put it in there so we'd be prepared for book 7." Then she wasn't even doing the Patronus! I'm sure she was very important in the Hogwarts Rebellion, but we didn't get to see any of that. I think I would have accepted another ten pages or so, just to have a chapter about Hogwarts.

Also, OMG. He does have terrible teeth, though.

gravatar srah - July 24, 2007 - 11:30 PM -

He is 18, though.

Not that I looked it up.

Ahem.

gravatar alfie - July 25, 2007 - 12:25 AM -

Yes. He's 18 and Rupert Grint will be 19 on your "birthday." It's slightly less creepy for me to look them up.

gravatar EV - July 25, 2007 - 10:54 AM -

Well, he's a Brit, you can't really count tooth issues.

gravatar srah - July 25, 2007 - 12:27 PM -

Percy Weasley isn't bad either. And slightly more age-appropriate. Even though Percy is a git.

Blog Directory - Blogged